EmailEmail
PrintPrint
As plot drops off, 'Man on Ledge' loses its edge
Movie Review
Friday, January 27, 2012

"Man on a Ledge" would have been much more impressive before Dec. 16.

That was when "Mission: Impossible -- Ghost Protocol" arrived in theaters with Tom Cruise treating the world's tallest tower like an indoor rock-climbing wall. He wasn't just teetering on a ledge 21 stories up in Manhattan.

True, Mr. Cruise's derring-do is just a fraction of that movie while much of "Man on a Ledge" takes place on a 14-inch stone shelf outside a room on the 21st floor of a Manhattan hotel.

That is where Nick Cassidy (Sam Worthington), a disgraced cop turned prison escapee, heads after ordering some champagne and food and writing a note that declares: "I will exit this world as I entered -- innocent."


'Man on a Ledge'

2 1/2 stars = Average
Ratings explained
  • Starring: Sam Worthington, Elizabeth Banks, Jamie Bell.
  • Rating: PG-13 for violence and brief strong language.
  • Web site: www.manonaledge.com

The story spins back to his incarceration in Sing Sing, denial of his final appeal and temporary release for a family funeral. He makes a violent break for it in the cemetery and finds his way to the Roosevelt Hotel at 45th Street and Madison Avenue.

When police show up, Nick threatens to jump unless NYPD negotiator Lydia Spencer (Elizabeth Banks) appears in 30 minutes. She arrives with a hangover and the sickening shadow of a previous case gone bad, but she (and we) have to figure out who Nick is, why he's 200 feet above the street and where others on both sides of the law factor into his apparent dance with death.

To fully enjoy "Man on a Ledge," you should take your critical faculties and lock them in one of those little hotel safes. Otherwise, you may think just what Nick's brother (Jamie Bell) fears: "He's an escaped felon -- they're gonna kill him."

But little is what it seems in the movie also featuring Anthony Mackie as Nick's best friend on the force; Ed Burns as another hostage negotiator; Ed Harris as an arrogant businessman who is all muscle and menace; Genesis Rodriguez as the girlfriend of Mr. Bell's character; Titus Welliver as another NYPD cop; and Kyra Sedgwick as a TV reporter who will be front and center if the jumper goes splat.

The throng on the ground is oddly small, even if the cops did close the block. Still, there's a bit of a "Dog Day Afternoon" vibe as the allegiance shifts and the crowd plays an unwitting role in Nick's scheme.

Asger Leth, who won a Directors Guild of America award four years ago for his documentary "Ghosts of Cite Soleil" about two brothers who are gang leaders in a notorious Haitian slum, directs a screenplay by Pablo F. Fenjves, who largely has penned TV movies.

The production built three versions of the hotel room set, including one on the top of the hotel that gives the movie authenticity, if not acrophobia. Still, "Man on a Ledge" may be even more implausible than "Contraband," particularly in the way the story wraps up faster than a speeding bullet.

With its threads about a cop wrongfully condemned to 25 years in prison, a breakneck escape, a negotiator in need of redemption, criminals who deserve a comeuppance, a heist and a couple of surprises, "Man" tries to give moviegoers plenty of reasons to get off the fence, if not the ledge.

Movie editor Barbara Vancheri: bvancheri@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1632. Read her blog: www.post-gazette.com/madaboutmovies.

First published on January 27, 2012 at 12:00 am